World Library  
Flag as Inappropriate
Email this Article

Felix Frankfurter

Article Id: WHEBN0000356028
Reproduction Date:

Title: Felix Frankfurter  
Author: World Heritage Encyclopedia
Language: English
Subject: List of law clerks of the Supreme Court of the United States, Hugo Black, William O. Douglas, Stanley Forman Reed, Robert H. Jackson
Collection: 1882 Births, 1965 Deaths, American Civil Liberties Union People, American Jewish Congress, American Jews, American Legal Scholars, American Legal Writers, American People of Austrian-Jewish Descent, American People of World War I, American Zionists, Austro-Hungarian Emigrants to the United States, Austro-Hungarian Jews, Burials at Mount Auburn Cemetery, Cardiovascular Disease Deaths in Washington, D.C., City College of New York Alumni, Deaths from Congestive Heart Failure, Franklin D. Roosevelt Administration Personnel, Harvard Law School Alumni, Harvard Law School Faculty, Jewish American Attorneys, New York Lawyers, People from New York City, Presidential Medal of Freedom Recipients, Townsend Harris High School Alumni, United States Federal Judges Appointed by Franklin D. Roosevelt, United States Presidential Advisors, United States Supreme Court Justices
Publisher: World Heritage Encyclopedia

Felix Frankfurter

Felix Frankfurter
Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court
In office
January 20, 1939[1] – August 28, 1962
Nominated by Franklin D. Roosevelt
Preceded by Benjamin N. Cardozo
Succeeded by Arthur Goldberg
Personal details
Born (1882-11-15)November 15, 1882
Vienna, Austria-Hungary
Died February 22, 1965(1965-02-22) (aged 82)
Washington, D.C.
Spouse(s) Marion Denman
Alma mater Harvard Law School
City College of New York
Religion Judaism

Felix Frankfurter (November 15, 1882 – February 22, 1965) was a jurist, who served as an Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court. Frankfurter was born in Vienna and immigrated to New York at the age of 12. He graduated from Harvard Law School and was active politically, helping to found the American Civil Liberties Union. He was a friend and adviser of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who appointed him to the Supreme Court in 1939. Frankfurter served on the Supreme Court for 23 years, and was a noted advocate of judicial restraint in the judgments of the Court.


  • Early life and education 1
  • Early career 2
  • First World War 3
  • Postwar 4
    • Marriage and family 4.1
    • Founding ACLU 4.2
  • New Deal years 5
  • Supreme Court 6
  • Personal relations on the Court 7
  • Initial skepticism of the Holocaust 8
  • Bibliography 9
  • Retirement, death and legacy 10
  • See also 11
  • References 12
  • Further reading 13
  • External links 14

Early life and education

Frankfurter was born into a Jewish family on November 15, 1882, in Vienna, Austria, then part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire. He was the third of six children of Leopold Frankfurter, a merchant, and Emma (Winter) Frankfurter.[2] His forebears had been rabbis for generations.[3] In 1894, when he was twelve, his family immigrated to New York City, settling on the Lower East Side, a dense center of immigrants. Frankfurter attended P.S. 25, where he excelled at his studies and enjoyed chess and crap shooting on the street. He spent many hours reading at The Cooper Union for he Advancement of Science and Art and attending political lectures, usually on subjects such as trade unionism, socialism and communism.[4][5]

After graduating in 1902 from City College of New York, where he was inducted into Phi Beta Kappa,[6] Frankfurter worked for the Tenement House Department of New York City to raise money for law school. He applied successfully to Harvard Law School, where he excelled academically and socially. He became lifelong friends with Walter Lippmann and Horace Kallen, became an editor of the Harvard Law Review, and graduated with one of the best academic records since Louis Brandeis.[4][7]

Early career

Frankfurter's legal career began when he joined the New York law firm of Hornblower, Byrne, Miller & Potter in 1906. In the same year, he was hired as the assistant to Henry Stimson, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York.[8] During this period, Frankfurter read Herbert Croly's book The Promise of American Life, and became a supporter of the New Nationalism and of Theodore Roosevelt. In 1911, President William Howard Taft appointed Stimson as his Secretary of War, and Stimson appointed Frankfurter as law officer of the Bureau of Insular Affairs. Frankfurter worked directly for Stimson as his assistant and confidant. His government position restricted his ability to publicly voice his Progressive views, though he expressed his opinions privately to friends such as Judge Learned Hand.[9] In 1912 Frankfurter supported the Bull Moose campaign to return Roosevelt to the presidency, and was bitterly disappointed when Woodrow Wilson was elected. He became increasingly disillusioned with the established parties, and described himself as "politically homeless".[10]

First World War

Frankfurter's work in Washington had impressed the faculty at Harvard Law School, who used a donation from the financier Jacob Schiff to create a position for him there. He taught mainly administrative law and occasionally criminal law.[11] With fellow professor James M. Landis, he advocated judicial restraint in dealing with government misdeeds, including greater freedom for administrative agencies from judicial oversight.[12] He also served as counsel for the National Consumers League, arguing for Progressive causes such as minimum wage and restricted work hours.[3][11] He was involved in the early years of The New Republic magazine after its founding by Herbert Croly.[3][13]

When the United States entered World War I in 1917, Frankfurter took a special leave from Harvard to serve as special assistant to the Secretary of War Newton D. Baker.[14] He was appointed Judge Advocate General, supervising military courts-martial for the War Department.[15] He was commissioned a major in the Officers Reserve Corps but was not called to active duty.

In September 1917, he was appointed counsel to a commission, the President's Mediation Committee, established by President Wilson to resolve major strikes threatening war production. Among the disturbances he investigated were the 1916 Preparedness Day Bombing in San Francisco, where he argued strongly that the radical leader Thomas Mooney had been Frameup and required a new trial.[16] He also examined the copper industry in Arizona, where industry bosses solved industrial relations problems by having more than 1,000 strikers forcibly deported to New Mexico.[17] Overall, Frankfurter's work gave him an opportunity to learn firsthand about labor politics and extremism, including anarchism, communism and revolutionary socialism. He came to sympathize with labor issues, arguing that "unsatisfactory, remediable social conditions, if unattended, give rise to radical movements far transcending the original impulse." His activities led the public to view him as a radical lawyer and supporter of radical principles.[16] Former President Theodore Roosevelt accused him of being "engaged in excusing men precisely like the Bolsheviki in Russia."[18]


As the war drew to a close, Frankfurter was among the nearly one hundred intellectuals who signed a statement of principles for the formation of the League of Free Nations Associations, intended to increase United States participation in international affairs.[19]

Frankfurter was encouraged by Supreme Court Justice

Legal offices
Preceded by
Benjamin N. Cardozo
Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States
January 20, 1939 – August 28, 1962
Succeeded by
Arthur Goldberg
  • Felix Frankfurter's Gravesite at Find a Grave
  • Oyez: U.S. Supreme Court media on Felix Frankfurter
  • Supreme Court Historical Society, Felix Frankfurther.
  • "Finding aid for Felix Frankfurter, Papers, 1900–1965.". Harvard Law School Library. 
  • The personal papers of Felix Frankfurter are kept at the Central Zionist Archives in Jerusalem. The notation of the record group is A264.
  • September 27, 2006 Epoch Times Editorial on Harry Wu (quotation referring to Jan Karski and Felix Frankfurter: When Jan Karski disclosed the message of Nazis' slaughtering of the Jews, the U.S. Supreme Court judge Felix Frankfurter's response to a Polish diplomat was, "Mr. Ambassador, I did not say this young man is lying. I said I am unable to believe him. There is a difference.") Harry Wu’s quote, is anecdotal and its accuracy is suspect. There is, however, no substantive difference between the two quotations, the one cited above and the filmed interview given by Karski himself in 1978.

External links

  • Abraham, Henry J., Justices and Presidents: A Political History of Appointments to the Supreme Court. 3d. ed. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1992). ISBN 0-19-506557-3.
  • Alexander, Michael (2001), Jazz Age Jews, Princeton University Press, .  
  • Ball, Howard (2006), Hugo Black: Cold Steel Warrior, New York: Oxford University Press, .  
  • Cushman, Clare, The Supreme Court Justices: Illustrated Biographies,1789–1995 (2nd ed.) (Supreme Court Historical Society), (Congressional Quarterly Books, 2001) ISBN 1-56802-126-7; ISBN 978-1-56802-126-3.
  • Carrington, Paul (1999), Stewards of Democracy: Law as Public Profession, New York: Basic Books, .  
  • Dworkin, Ronald (1996), Freedom's Law: The Moral Reading of the American Constitution, Oxford: Oxford University Press, .  
  • Eisler, Kim Isaac (1993), A Justice for All: William J. Brennan, Jr., and the decisions that transformed America, New York: Simon & Schuster, .  
  • Frank, John P. (2006), Leon Friedman and Fred L. Israel, ed., The Justices of the United States Supreme Court: Their Lives and Major Opinions, Chelsea House Publishers, .  
  • Frankfurter, Felix, Mr. Justice Cardozo and Public Law, Columbia Law Review 39 (1939): 88–118, Harvard Law Review 52 (1939): 440–470, Yale Law Journal 48 (1939): 458–488.
  • Gunther, Gerald (1994), Learned Hand: The Man and the Judge, New York: Knopf, .  
  • Hirsh, H.N. (1981), The Enigma of Felix Frankfurter, New York: Basic Books, .  
  • Irons, Peter (1999), A People's History of the Supreme Court, New York: Viking Penguin, .  
  • Hockett, Jeffry D (1996), New Deal Justice: The Constitutional Jurisprudence of Hugo L. Black, Felix Frankfurter, and Robert H. Jackson, Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, .  
  • Kennedy, David M. (2001), Freedom from Fear: The American People in Depression and War, 1929–1945, Oxford University Press US, .  
  • Maguire, Peter H. (2000), Law and War: An American Story, Columbia University Press, .  
  • Martin, Fenton S. and Goehlert, Robert U., The U.S. Supreme Court: A Bibliography, (Congressional Quarterly Books, 1990). ISBN 0-87187-554-3.
  • Murphy, Bruce Allen, The Brandeis/Frankfurter Connection: The Secret Political Activities of Two Supreme Court Justices, (New York: Oxford University Press, 1982). ISBN 0-19-503122-9.
  • Murphy, Bruce Allen; Owens, Arthur (2003), Vile, John R., ed., Great American Judges: An Encyclopedia 1, Santa Barbara: ABC–CLIO, .  
  • Parrish, Michael H. (1996), "Felix Frankfurter, the Progressive Tradition and the Warren Court", The Warren Court: In Historical and Political Perspective, University of Virginia Press, .  
  • Pritchett, C. Herman, Civil Liberties and the Vinson Court (The University of Chicago Press, 1969) ISBN 978-0-226-68443-7; ISBN 0-226-68443-1.
  • Stone, Geoffrey R. (2004), Perilous Times: Free Speech in Wartime From the Sedition Act of 1798 to the War on Terrorism, New York: Norton, .  
  • Urofsky, Melvin I., Conflict Among the Brethren: Felix Frankfurter, William O. Douglas and the Clash of Personalities and Philosophies on the United States Supreme Court, Duke Law Journal (1988): 71–113.
  • Urofsky, Melvin I., Division and Discord: The Supreme Court under Stone and Vinson, 1941–1953 (University of South Carolina Press, 1997) ISBN 1-57003-120-7.
  • Urofsky, Melvin I., The Supreme Court Justices: A Biographical Dictionary (New York: Garland Publishing 1994). 590 pp. ISBN 0-8153-1176-1; ISBN 978-0-8153-1176-8.
  • White, G. Edward (2007), The American Judicial Tradition: Profiles of Leading American Judges (3rd ed.), Oxford: Oxford University Press, .  
  • Woodward, Bob; Armstrong, Scott (1979), The Brethren: inside the Supreme Court, New York: Simon and Schuster, .  

Further reading

  1. ^ Federal Judicial Center: Felix Frankfurter, December 12, 2009, retrieved December 12, 2009 
  2. ^ Mishra, Patit P. (2007). "Felix Frankfurter". In Ciment, James D.; Russell, Thaddeus. The Home Front Encyclopedia: United States, Britain, And Canada in World Wars I And II. ABC-CLIO. pp. 76–77.  
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h Slater, Elinor; Slater, Robert (1996), Great Jewish Men, Jonathan David Company, Inc, pp. 112–115,  
  4. ^ a b Murphy 2003, p. 264
  5. ^ Alexander 2001, p. 77
  6. ^ Knott, K. (2009). Supreme Court Justices Who Are Phi Beta Kappa Members. Phi Beta Kappa web site. Retrieved on October 4, 2009 from
  7. ^ Alexander 2001, pp. 77–8
  8. ^ Murphy 2003, pp. 264–65
  9. ^ Gunther 1994, pp. 221–22
  10. ^ Alexander 2001, p. 82
  11. ^ a b Alexander 2001, pp. 83–4
  12. ^ Carrington 1999, p. 132
  13. ^ Gunther 1994, p. 244
  14. ^ Gunther 1994, p. 253
  15. ^ Irons 1999, p. 267
  16. ^ a b Alexander 2001, pp. 84–7
  17. ^ Gunther 1994, pp. 353–4
  18. ^ a b c d e Murphy 2003, p. 265
  19. ^ Gunther 1994, p. 261
  20. ^ June 20, 1938Time Magazine,
  21. ^ Polenberg, Richard (2007), "Introduction", The Letters of Sacco and Vanzetti, Penguin Classics, xxi,  
  22. ^ Gunther 1994, p. 358
  23. ^ Irons 1999, p. 283
  24. ^ Stone 2004, pp. 225–26
  25. ^ Morris, Norval; David J. Rothman (1995), The Oxford History of the Prison: The Practice of Punishment in Western Society, Oxford: Oxford University Press, p. 358,  
  26. ^ Gunther 1994, pp. 362–65
  27. ^ Rogers, Alan (2008), Murder and the Death Penalty in Massachusetts, University of Massachusetts Press, pp. 187–94,  
  28. ^
  29. ^ a b
  30. ^ a b Gunther 1994, p. 437
  31. ^ a b c Murphy 2003, p. 266
  32. ^ Berlin, Isaiah (2001), "Felix Frankfurter at Oxford", in Hardy, Henry, Personal Impressions, Princeton University Press, pp. 112–19,  
  33. ^ Irons 1999, pp. 327–8
  34. ^
  35. ^ "A History of Supreme.Confirmation Hearings". July 12, 2009. Retrieved April 23, 2010. 
  36. ^ [2]
  37. ^ a b c Irons 1999, p. 328
  38. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 121
  39. ^ Eisler 1993, pp. 161–162
  40. ^ Irons 1999, pp. 338–341
  41. ^ Irons 1999, pp. 344–345
  42. ^ White, James Boyd (2006), Living Speech: Resisting the Empire of Force, Princeton University Press, pp. 45–47,  
  43. ^ a b c Eisler 1993, p. 11
  44. ^ Carrington 1999, pp. 142–43
  45. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 12
  46. ^ a b Stone 2004, pp. 402–10
  47. ^ Michael Lariens on Fred Vinson.
  48. ^ a b Woodward and Armstrong 1979, p. 38
  49. ^ Woodward and Armstrong 1979, pp. 37–38
  50. ^ Woodward and Armstrong 1979, p. 55
  51. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 128
  52. ^ The Supreme Court Under Earl Warren, 1953–1969. By Michal R. Belknap, Earl Warren. Page 95. University of South Carolina Press.
  53. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 129
  54. ^ Dworkin 1996, p. 340
  55. ^ Greenhouse, Linda (August 30, 2006), "Supreme Court Memo; Women Suddenly Scarce Among Justices' Clerks", The New York Times, retrieved November 28, 2008 
  56. ^ Lewis, Neil A. (June 15, 1993), "THE SUPREME COURT: Woman in the News; Rejected as a Clerk, Chosen as a Justice: Ruth Joan Bader Ginsburg", The New York Times, retrieved August 2, 2015 
  57. ^
  58. ^ Eisler 1993, pp. 88, 100, 105
  59. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 100
  60. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 106
  61. ^ Eisler 1993, p. 102
  62. ^ Hirsch 1981, p. 188
  63. ^ a b Hirsch 1981, pp. 189–90
  64. ^ Murphy, Wild Bill: The Legend and Life of William O. Douglas at 327 (New York: Random House 2003).
  65. ^ Hirsch 1981, p. 190
  66. ^ Ball 2006, p. 14
  67. ^ Ball 2006, pp. 212–213
  68. ^ Ball 2006, p. 213
  69. ^ Parrish 1996, p. 52
  70. ^ Ball, Howard. Hugo L. Black: Cold Steel Warrior. Oxford University Press. 2006. ISBN 0-19-507814-4. Page 140.
  71. ^ a b Hirsch 1981, p. 187
  72. ^ Hirsch 1981, pp. 187–88
  73. ^ Wrightsman, Lawrence S.; La Mort, Justin R. (Fall 2005), "Why Do Supreme Court Justices Succeed or Fail? Harry Blackmun as an Example" (PDF), Missouri Law Review 70 (4): 1261–87 
  74. ^ Ball, Howard. Hugo L. Black: Cold Steel Warrior. Oxford University Press. 2006. ISBN 0-19-507814-4. Page 137.
  75. ^
  76. ^ "Jan Karski about his meeting with Supreme Court Justice Felix Frankfurter, 1943"
  77. ^
  78. ^ Felix Frankfurter memorial at University of Alabama.


See also

There are two extensive collections of Frankfurter's papers: one at the Manuscript Division of the Aleph Zadik Aleph in Scottsdale, AZ is named in his honor.

Felix Frankfurter died from congestive heart failure in 1965 at the age of 82. His remains are interred in the Mount Auburn Cemetery in Cambridge, Massachusetts.[78]

Frankfurter retired in 1962 after suffering a stroke and was succeeded by Arthur Goldberg. He was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 1963.

Retirement, death and legacy

Frankfurter, Felix, and James M. Landis. 1925. "The Compact Clause of the Constitution: A Study in Interstate Adjustments." Yale Law Journal 34, No. 7: 685 - 758.[77]

Frankfurter published several books including Cases Under the Interstate Commerce Act; The Business of the Supreme Court (1927); Justice Holmes and the Supreme Court (1938); The Case of Sacco and Vanzetti (1927) and Felix Frankfurter Reminisces (1960).


A member of the Polish resistance, Jan Karski, had been smuggled into the Warsaw ghetto and a camp near the Belzec death camp in 1942, in order to report back on what is now known as the Holocaust. In July 1943 he was interviewed by Frankfurter on behalf of the President, and was greeted with skepticism. Frankfurter later said "I did not say that he was lying, I said that I could not believe him. There is a difference."[75][76]

Initial skepticism of the Holocaust

Frankfurter was universally praised for his work before coming to the Supreme Court, and was expected to influence it for decades past the death of FDR.[73] However, Frankfurter's influence over other justices was limited by his failure to adapt to new surroundings, his style of personal relations (relying heavily on the use of flattery and ingratiation, which ultimately proved divisive), and his strict adherence to the ideology of judicial restraint. Michael E. Parrish, professor at UCSD, said of Frankfurter: "History has not been kind to [him]... there is now almost a universal consensus that Frankfurter the justice was a failure, a judge who... became 'uncoupled from the locomotive of history' during the Second World War, and who thereafter left little in the way of an enduring jurisprudential legacy."[74]

Frankfurter was close friends with Justice Robert H. Jackson.[71] The two exchanged much correspondence over their mutual dislike for Justice William O. Douglas.[71] Frankfurter also had a strong influence over Jackson's opinions.[72]

Frankfurter's argumentative style was not popular among his Supreme Court colleagues. "All Frankfurter does is talk, talk, talk," Chief Justice Earl Warren complained. "He drives you crazy."[37][69] Hugo Black reported that "I thought Felix was going to hit me today, he got so mad."[37] In the Court's biweekly conference sessions, traditionally a period for vote-counting, Frankfurter had the habit of lecturing his colleagues for forty-five minutes at a time or more with his book resting on a podium. Frankfurter's ideological opponents would leave the room or read their mail while he lectured.[70]

Frankfurter saw justices with ideas different from his own as part of a more liberal "Axis" – these opponents were chiefly Justices Black and Douglas, but would also include Murphy and Rutledge; the group would for years oppose Frankfurter's judicially restrained ideology.[66] Douglas, Murphy, and then Rutledge were the first justices to agree with Hugo Black's notion that the Fourteenth Amendment incorporated the Bill of Rights protection into it; this view would later mostly become law, during the period of the Warren Court.[67] For his part, Frankfurter would assert that Black's incorporation theory would usurp state control over criminal justice by limiting states' development of new interpretations of criminal due process.[68]

Justice Frankfurter was in his time the leader of the conservative faction of the Supreme Court; he would for many years feud with liberals like Justices Black and Douglas.[43] He often complained that they "started with a result" and that their work was "shoddy," "result-oriented," and "demagogic".[63] Similarly, Frankfurter panned the work of Chief Justice Earl Warren as "dishonest nonsense."[65]

Throughout his career on the court, Frankfurter was a large influence on many justices, such as Clark, Burton, Whittaker, and Minton.[58] He generally attempted to influence any new justice coming in,[59] though he managed to repel Justice Brennan – who had voted with Frankfurter half the time in his first year,[60] but then opposed him after Frankfurter's attempts at inculcation.[61] Frankfurter turned against Brennan completely after the case of Irvin v. Dowd. Other justices who received the Frankfurter treatment of flattery and instruction were Burton, Vinson, and Harlan.[62] With Vinson, who became Chief Justice, Frankfurter feigned deference, though he sought influence.[63] Upon learning of Vinson's death in 1953, Frankfurter exclaimed, "This is the first solid piece of evidence I've ever had that there really is a God."[64]

Personal relations on the Court

In 1960, despite a recommendation from the dean of Harvard Law School, Frankfurter turned down Ruth Bader Ginsburg for a clerkship position because of her gender.[56] Ginsburg later became an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court, thereby re-establishing the so-called "Jewish seat" on the Court once occupied by Frankfurter.[57]

For the October 1948 court term, Frankfurter hired William Thaddeus Coleman as a law clerk, the first African American to serve as a Supreme Court law clerk.[55]

Frankfurter believed that the authority of the Supreme Court would be reduced if it went too strongly against public opinion: He sometimes went to great lengths to avoid unpopular decisions, including fighting to delay court decisions against laws prohibiting racial intermarriage.[54]

Later in his career, Frankfurter's judicial restraint philosophy frequently put him on the dissenting side of ground-breaking decisions taken by the Warren Court to end discrimination.

Frankfurter was hands-off in the area of business. In the 1956 government case against DuPont, started because DuPont seemed to have maneuvered its way into a preferential relationship with GM, Frankfurter refused to find a conspiracy, and said the Court had no right to interfere with the progress of business.[51][52] Here again, Frankfurter opposed the views of Justices Warren, Black, Douglas, and Brennan (though Frankfurter lost 4–3).[53]

Frankfurter demanded that the opinion in Brown II (1955) order schools to desegregate with "all deliberate speed".[48] Some school boards used this phrase as an excuse to defy the demands of the first Brown decision.[48] For fifteen years, schools in many states of the South remained segregated; in some cases systems closed their schools, and new private, Christian schools were opened by white parents for their children.[49] In Alexander v. Holmes County Board of Education, the Court wrote, "The obligation of every school district is to terminate dual school systems at once and to operate now and hereafter only unitary schools."[50]

A pivotal school desegregation case came before the court in Brown v. Board of Education. It was argued, and was set for reargument when Chief Justice Fred M. Vinson died. It has been reported that Frankfurter remarked that Vinson's death was the first solid piece of evidence he had seen to prove the existence of God. It should be noted that this story was tied to a scheduled reargument in which Vinson's vote could be crucial (where ostensibly Vinson was not disposed to overrule Plessy v. Ferguson). Some believe the story to be "possibly apocryphal."[47]

Frankfurter reaffirmed this view in a concurring opinion written for the 1951 Dennis v. United States Supreme Court ruling. The decision affirmed, by a 6–2 margin, the conviction of eleven communist leaders for conspiring to overthrow the US government under the Smith Act. In it, he again argued that judges "are not legislators, that direct policy-making is not our province."[46] He recognized that curtailing the free speech of those who advocate the overthrow of government by force, also risked stifling criticism by those who did not, writing that "[it] is a sobering fact that in sustaining the convictions before us we can hardly escape restriction on the interchange of ideas."[46]

In the apportionment case of Baker v. Carr, Frankfurter's position was that the federal courts did not have the right to tell sovereign state governments how to apportion their legislatures; he thought the Supreme Court should not get involved in political questions, whether federal or local.[43] Frankfurter's view had won out in the 1946 case preceding Baker, Colegrove v. Green – there, a 4–3 majority decided that the case was non-justiciable, and the federal courts had no right to become involved in state politics, no matter how unequal district populations had become.[43][44] But, in the Baker case, the majority of justices ruled to settle the matter – saying that the drawing of state legislative districts was within the purview of federal judges, despite Frankfurter's warnings that the Court should avoid entering "the political thicket."[45]

Frankfurter's adherence to the judicial restraint philosophy was shown in the 1940 opinion he wrote for the court in Minersville School District v. Gobitis, a case involving Jehovah's Witnesses students who had been expelled from school due to their refusal to salute the flag and recite the Pledge of Allegiance. He rejected claims that First Amendment rights should be protected by law, and urged deference to the decisions of the elected school board officials. He stated that religious belief "does not relieve the citizen from the discharge of political responsibilities" and that exempting the children from the flag-saluting ceremony "might cast doubts in the minds of other children" and reduce their loyalty to the nation. Justice Harlan Fiske Stone issued a lone dissent. The court's decision was followed by hundreds of violent attacks on Jehovah's Witnesses throughout the country.[40] It was overturned in March 1943 by the Supreme Court decision on West Virginia Board of Education v. Barnette. A frequent ally, Supreme Court justice Robert H. Jackson, wrote the majority opinion in this case, which reversed the decision only three years prior in poetic passionate terms as a fundamental constitutional principle, that no government authority has the right to define official dogma and require its affirmation by citizens. Frankfurter's extensive dissent began by raising and then rejecting the notion that as a Jew, he ought "to particularly protect minorities." He reiterated his view that the role of the Court was not to give an opinion of the "wisdom or evil of a law" but only to determine "whether legislators could in reason have enacted such a law".[41][42]

In his judicial restraint philosophy, Frankfurter was strongly influenced by his close friend and mentor Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., who had taken a firm stand during his tenure on the bench against the doctrine of "economic due process". Frankfurter revered Justice Holmes, often citing Holmes in his opinions. In practice, this meant Frankfurter was generally willing to uphold the actions of those branches against constitutional challenges so long as they did not "shock the conscience." Frankfurter was particularly well known as a scholar of civil procedure.

Frankfurter became the court's most outspoken advocate of judicial restraint, the view that courts should not interpret the fundamental law, the constitution, in such a way as to impose sharp limits upon the authority of the legislative and executive branches.[37] He also usually refused to apply the federal Constitution to the states.[38] In the case of Irvin v. Dowd, Frankfurter stated what was for him a frequent theme: "The federal judiciary has no power to sit in judgment upon a determination of a state court... Something that thus goes to the very structure of our federal system in its distribution of power between the United States and the state is not a mere bit of red tape to be cut, on the assumption that this Court has general discretion to see justice done...".[39]

Following the death of Supreme Court Justice Benjamin N. Cardozo in July 1938, President Franklin D. Roosevelt asked his old friend Frankfurter for recommendations of prospective candidates for the vacancy. Finding none on the list to suit his criteria, Roosevelt nominated Frankfurter.[33] The Senate confirmation hearing on the nomination of Frankfurter was notable for the opposition which arose. In addition to the objection that he was considered to be the President's unofficial advisor, that he was affiliated with special interest groups, that there were now no justices from west of the Mississippi, opposing groups and individuals appearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee pointed to Frankfurter as foreign-born and deemed to be affiliated with an anti-Christian movement viewed as part of a broader Communist infiltration into the country.[34] Twenty-nine people who testified against the nomination during the hearings led to their indictment in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia in July 1942 for sedition. They were imprisoned for varying terms, the last being freed five years after the death of Franklin Roosevelt. The controversy permanently changed the process which had been followed for 150 years, being the first time that a nominee for the Supreme Court appeared in person before the Judiciary Committee.[35] He served from January 30, 1939 to August 28, 1962. He wrote 247 opinions for the Court, 132 concurring opinions, and 251 dissents.[36]

Frankfurter's Supreme Court nomination

Supreme Court

Frankfurter successfully recommended many bright young lawyers toward public service with the New Deal administration; they became known as "Felix's Happy Hot Dogs".[30][31] Among the most notable of these were Thomas Corcoran Donald and Alger Hiss, and Benjamin Cohen. He moved to Washington, DC, commuting back to Harvard for classes, but felt that he was never fully accepted within government circles. He worked closely with Louis Brandeis, lobbying for political activities suggested by Brandeis. He declined a seat on the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts and, in 1933, the position of Solicitor General of the United States.[31] Long an anglophile, Frankfurter had studied at Oxford University in 1920. In 1933–34 he returned to act as visiting Eastman professor in the faculty of Law.[31][32]

Following the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932, Frankfurter quickly became a trusted and loyal adviser to the new president. Frankfurter was considered to be liberal[28] and advocated progressive legislation.[29] However, he was also a firm believer in judicial restraint.[29] He argued against the economic plans of Raymond Moley, Adolf Berle and Rexford Tugwell (1891-1979), while recognizing the need for major changes to deal with the inequalities of wealth distribution that had led to the devastating nature of the Great Depression.[30]

New Deal years

In the late 1920s, he attracted public attention when he supported calls for a new trial for Sacco and Vanzetti, two Italian immigrant anarchists who had been sentenced to death on robbery and murder charges. Frankfurter wrote an influential article for the Atlantic Monthly and subsequently a book, The Case of Sacco and Vanzetti: A Critical Analysis for Lawyers and Laymen. He critiqued the prosecution's case and the judge's handling of the trial; he asserted that the convictions were the result of anti-immigrant prejudice and enduring anti-radical hysteria of the Red Scare of 1919–20.[3][27] His activities further isolated him from his Harvard colleagues and from Boston society.[18]

In 1921, Frankfurter was given a chair at Harvard Law School, where he continued progressive work on behalf of socialists and oppressed and religious minorities. When A. Lawrence Lowell, the President of Harvard University, proposed to limit the enrollment of Jewish students, Frankfurter worked with others to defeat the plan.[18][26]

[25][24][23] Frankfurter's activities continued to attract attention for their alleged radicalism. In November 1919, he chaired a meeting in support of American recognition of the newly created

Founding ACLU

In 1919, Frankfurter married Marion Denman, a Smith College graduate and the daughter of a Congregational minister. They married after a long and difficult courtship, and against the wishes of his mother, who was disturbed by the prospect of her son marrying outside the Jewish faith.[18][21] Frankfurter was a non-practicing Jew, and regarded religion as "an accident of birth". Frankfurter was a domineering husband and Denman suffered from frail health. She suffered frequent mental breakdowns.[18] The couple had no children.

Marriage and family

[3].Paris Peace Conference delegate to the Zionist In 1919, Frankfurter served as a [20]

This article was sourced from Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. World Heritage Encyclopedia content is assembled from numerous content providers, Open Access Publishing, and in compliance with The Fair Access to Science and Technology Research Act (FASTR), Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., Public Library of Science, The Encyclopedia of Life, Open Book Publishers (OBP), PubMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Center for Biotechnology Information, U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health (NIH), U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, and, which sources content from all federal, state, local, tribal, and territorial government publication portals (.gov, .mil, .edu). Funding for and content contributors is made possible from the U.S. Congress, E-Government Act of 2002.
Crowd sourced content that is contributed to World Heritage Encyclopedia is peer reviewed and edited by our editorial staff to ensure quality scholarly research articles.
By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. World Heritage Encyclopedia™ is a registered trademark of the World Public Library Association, a non-profit organization.

Copyright © World Library Foundation. All rights reserved. eBooks from World Library are sponsored by the World Library Foundation,
a 501c(4) Member's Support Non-Profit Organization, and is NOT affiliated with any governmental agency or department.